Connect with us

My Wordpress

Bernie Sanders Hasn’t Killed Identity Politics


Bernie Sanders Hasn’t Killed Identity Politics

Bernie Sanders Hasn’t Killed Identity Politics

Photo: Saul Loeb/AFP/Getty Images

Maybe we’re being haunted for our sins. The 2016 Democratic primary ought to be over, but it looks alive, or at least undead. Occasionally it moans: Medicare for All just isn’t reasonable and heartland voters love Aetna as a god. It usually shows up on Twitter, where all cursed thoughts go to holler. There, it recently sensed bait. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, Ilhan Omar, and (probably) Rashida Tlaib have endorsed Bernie Sanders for president, and behold:

Eisner, who is the academic director of the Columbia Journalism School, appears to have deleted her tweet. But her comment still breathed new life into a familiar old phantom. In the most literal sense, Bernie Sanders is not running against Hillary Clinton this year. But the acrimony generated by their contest lingers. It is palpable in Eisner’s failure to understand why Ocasio-Cortez and Omar would endorse Sanders, a man who, since he is also old and white, superficially has little in common with them. In Eisner’s reckoning, it’s as if identity operates on a points-based system, and whoever had the most points automatically wins voters who look most like them –  policies be damned.

But policy matters. It mattered in 2016, too, despite a common pretense to the contrary. There was generally a push from the Clinton camp to present their candidate as the sensible but progressive alternative to Sanders. At their most dogmatic, Clinton surrogates spoke of Sanders as if he were the antithesis to identity politics and as if support for him betrayed feminism itself. “We can tell our story of how we climbed the ladder, and a lot of you younger women think it’s done. It’s not done. There’s a special place in hell for women who don’t help each other!” Madeleine Albright said of female Sanders supporters in 2016. Stupid, but still preferable to Gloria Steinem’s apparent belief that young women picked candidates based on who they wanted to bone. “When you’re young, you’re thinking: ‘Where are the boys? The boys are with Bernie,’” she mused.

But the girls weren’t traitors, and they didn’t just want to get laid. They wanted Medicare for All. It was never that complicated. Anyone who picks their allegiances based on their community’s interests displays a form of identity politics. But on its own, the simple fact of shared identity does not an ally make. There is a vast gulf, politically, between Sarah Palin and Senator Elizabeth Warren. The gulf between the progressive Warren and a centrist like Amy Klobuchar is smaller, but real. Authentically practiced, identity politics does not mean that a person will rally around a member of their group. In 2016, many women believed their specific interests would be better served by a different theory of change. They had no time to wait on Clinton’s incrementalism, and no reason to trust her to take them where they needed to go. That’s still true now. Clinton’s centrism outlasted her political career: Its new avatars are Klobuchar and Joe Biden and Pete Buttigieg.

The perspective Eisner aired had already shown signs of unholy new life. “I actually overheard someone saying, that I thought was an interesting point, that basically at this point if you are still supporting Sanders as opposed to Warren, it’s kind of showing your sexism,” Democratic strategist Emily Tisch Sussman recently said on MSNBC. It’s not. Even if Warren is far closer to Sanders than she is to Clinton, Sanders supporters have substantive reasons to prefer the senator from Vermont over his friend from Massachusetts.

Applied to the congresswomen in particular, this apolitical grasp of identity is uniquely inadequate. On the stump and in comments to reporters, the two refer often to their backgrounds — to their gender, their ethnicities, their experiences with economic precarity and in Omar’s case, with war. Even if they wanted to forget who they are, Donald Trump wouldn’t let them. His attacks on the two congresswoman, and on their frequent allies Ayanna Pressley and Rashida Tlaib, reveal his specific antipathy for immigrants and Muslims and women. Trump doesn’t just want them to shut up, he wants them to “go back” to the “the totally broken and crime infested places from which they came.” When Trump went to Minnesota for a recent rally, he didn’t just attack Omar and her politics. He attacked the state’s Somali community, to which Omar belongs, by name.

It’s a strange notion, the idea that ideology and identity sit in separate boxes to be picked up or set down as someone sees fit. But they aren’t separate, which means they aren’t opposing forces, and one is never subservient to the other. Ideology and identity are wrapped up in each other, they shape each other, and this is as true for right-wing men as it is for left-wing women.

The congresswomen have explained this in their own words, over and over and over again. In the aggregate, they have probably explained their views more often than most politicians; that is the price of being an insurgent. Americans are so unused to leftists in office that the political philosophies of both women remained topics of national debate long after they’d finished their campaigns. Anyone curious about their presidential endorsement could least defer to their own words and deeds. Ocasio-Cortez volunteered for the Sanders campaign and describes herself as a democratic socialist, like the senator. She’s ably explained her ideology on multiple occasions. “I’m an educator, I’m an organizer, and I believe that what we’re really seeing is just a move for health care, housing and education in the United States,” she told NBC’s Chuck Todd in a key 2018 interview. “An important part of my strategy in winning was building a broad-based coalition of people. So while there’s a focus on this one aspect of the coalition. The definition of democratic socialism to me again is the fact that in a modern, moral and wealthy society no American should be too poor to live.”

Omar isn’t a member of DSA, even if Trump did just call her an “America-hating socialist.” But politically she aligns herself closely with Ocasio-Cortez and Sanders, with whom she recently introduced a sweeping bill to cancel student loan debt. She stated her rationale quite clearly on Tuesday, when she announced her endorsement. In a video released by the Sanders campaign, Omar describes the senator as “the only candidate that has built a movement and continues to build a movement that transcends gender, ethnicity, religion.”

“There was an America that I dreamed about,” she added. “There is an America that most people believe in. It is an ideal. It’s not a reality yet.” The dream is everything. That’s why she and Ocasio-Cortez endorsed Sanders. The goal isn’t a world where identity no longer matters, but where it doesn’t hold anyone back.

Yes, Identity Politics Still Matters

Promoted links by Taboola

The Popularity of Bernie Sanders Does Not Mean Identity Politics Is Over
By Sarah Jones

The goal isn’t a world where identity no longer matters, but where it doesn’t hold anyone back.

vision 2020
AOC Credits Sanders for Her Political Awakening at Bernie’s Big Comeback Rally
By Chas Danner

His campaign hopes the event, which is Sanders’s first since his heart attack a few weeks ago, will reignite the candidate’s momentum.

9:00 a.m.just asking questions

just asking questions
Author Tom Mueller on the ‘Minefield’ Facing the Trump-Ukraine Whistle-blower
By Matt Stieb

“If you don’t get the right path, you may blow up,” says Mueller, who argues in his new book that we’re living in a golden age of whistle-blowing.

Kasich Comes Out for Trump Impeachment
By Ed Kilgore

The former governor and 2016 candidate, like Mitt Romney, used to be a classic hardcore conservative. The GOP has changed a lot.

vision 2020
Gabbard Demands Clinton Enter 2020 Race, Calls Her ‘Queen of Warmongers’
By Ed Kilgore

The bizarre tweets follow the 2016 nominee’s implication that the current candidate is an agent of Russia.

vision 2020
Trump Believes He Has a Mandate for Tyranny
By Ed Kilgore

Given the vast powers Trump thinks voters gave him in 2016, what will he be like if he wins reelection? The mind reels.

10/18/2019the national interest

the national interest
Locating G7 Summit at Trump’s Own Property Is Genius, Conservative Argues
By Jonathan Chait

The Federalist columnist David Marcus argues that Trump is not only within his rights but brilliant for securing “home field advantage.”

10/18/2019democratic primaries

democratic primaries
Pete Buttigieg’s Chicago Fundraiser Debacle Won’t Help Him With Black Voters
By Zak Cheney-Rice

He needs black support for his new strategy: capturing Biden supporters if the former vice-president falters.

The Zuck’s Speech
By Brian Feldman

The Facebook CEO’s speech defending his right to not do anything and take no responsibility misses the point.

vision 2020
Bernie’s Back. And It’s Make-or-Break Time for His Campaign.
By Gabriel Debenedetti

The senator and presidential candidate has made his return to the trail, buoyed by an endorsement for Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez. What happens next?


Boeing only turned these messages over to the FAA on Thursday
Text messages between Boeing employees in 2016 indicate that the company was aware of major problems with an automated feature on the 737 Max jet that made the aircraft difficult to control, the messages show.Safety investigators say the system, known as MCAS, had repeatedly pushed the noses of planes down in Indonesia and Ethi­o­pia, contributing to crashes that killed 346 people in the past year.One text message with a misspelling said the feature was engaging “itself like craxy.” Another termed the problem “egregious.”Another indicated that the Boeing employees misled the Federal Aviation Administration. “So I basically lied to the regulators (unknowingly),” read one message.“It wasnt a lie, no one told us that was the case,” came the response.

Real Life. Real News. Real Voices

Help us tell more of the stories that matter

Become a founding member

10/18/2019the national interest

the national interest
Trump Writes Unhinged ‘Legal’ Letter Demanding That CNN Pay Him Money
By Jonathan Chait

Trump’s authoritarian side and his toddler side are both on display here.


Pompeo thinks its unfair that House Democrats won’t let State Department attorneys gather inside information on impeachment proceedings
Pompeo curtly declined to discuss Giuliani — “I have nothing to add,” he said — or Marie Yovanovitch, the ousted ambassador of Ukraine, who testified in the impeachment inquiry following a congressional subpoena. But America’s top diplomat took aim at the Democrats for what he sees as an unfair process, where state secrets are being put at risk and the department is being afforded little visibility into what its current and former employees are saying.“They’re not letting State Department lawyers in the room … they have not let State Department lawyers be part of these hearings,” Pompeo said. “That’s unheard of … I haven’t seen you all report that.”

vision 2020
Late-Entry Third-Party Threats Haunt Democrats
By Ed Kilgore

The sudden talk about centrist billionaires and “Russian assets” entering the 2020 sweepstakes reflects Democratic nightmares and rivalries.

10/18/2019foreign interests

foreign interests
Boris Johnson’s Make-or-Break Saturday Session in Parliament
By Jonah Shepp

The U.K. Parliament will convene for a rare and historic weekend vote in what could be the climax of the Brexit saga.


Meanwhile, up in space
NASA reached a milestone on Friday morning when two Americans ventured out of the International Space Station to replace a power controller: The astronauts, Jessica Meir and Christina Koch, had undertaken the first all-female spacewalk.Shortly before 8 a.m., live video of the event showed two bulky white figures — first Ms. Koch, then Ms. Meir — emerging slowly from the space station, which glowed against the blackness of space.The women could be heard talking to each other, and a helmet camera showed Ms. Meir’s view as she clambered along the outside of the space station on the way to her work station.At one point, she could be seen crossing beneath the dangling feet of Ms. Koch. “Right beneath your feet, so don’t move down,” she said.The spacewalk was expected to last for more than five hours.

What We Know About Trump’s Potential Senate Impeachment Trial
By Ed Kilgore

Impeachment trial procedures are an amalgam of constitutional provisions, standing Senate rules, and ad hoc procedures controlled by McConnell’s GOP.


Trump stands to profit off the kind of bigotry presidents used to denounce
Another anti-Muslim group has scheduled a fundraiser at Mar-a-Lago, prompting the nation’s largest Muslim advocacy group to again ask the Trump Organization to cancel an event sponsored by such a group.The Center for Security Policy, a Washington, DC think-tank whose founder, Frank Gaffney once suggested President Barack Obama was a Muslim and that Sharia law threatens American society, intends to host its annual Flame Dinner at Mar-a-Lago on Nov. 23. Tickets for the event start at $650, according to the Center’s website.Fred Fleitz, the Center’s president and CEO, said the group was not deterred by the Trump Organization’s abrupt decision on Oct. 6 to cancel an event hosted by another anti-Muslim group, ACT for America, after news of that group’s dinner plans grabbed national headlines and drew widespread criticism.“We are honored to have this event at Mar-a-Lago,” said Fleitz, adding that he has dined at the club many times.


Former Defense Secretary Mattis saved his Trump jabs for the Al Smith dinner
Delivering the keynote address at the 75th Alfred E. Smith Memorial Foundation Dinner in New York, Mattis — a retired four-star U.S. Marine general — said he felt he had finally “achieved greatness.”“I’m not just an overrated general, I am the greatest, the world’s most overrated,” he said to laughter.“I’m honored to be considered that by Donald Trump, because he also called Meryl Streep an overrated actress,” Mattis continued. “So, I guess I’m the Meryl Streep of generals. Frankly that sounds pretty good to me.”… “I earned my spurs on the battlefield … Donald Trump earned his spurs in a letter from a doctor,” he said in a reference to a medical deferment for bone spurs that kept Trump from serving in the military during the Vietnam War.

world view
Trump Is Letting Turkey Bully the United States
By Heather Hurlburt

The U.S. delegation got to announce a Syria cease-fire, but only after Ankara gave them a taste of the humiliation that weak nations endure regularly.

7 Unhinged Moments From Trump’s Dallas Rally
By Matt Stieb

Trump said that forces in Syria need to “scrap a little” and that Hurricane Harvey made Texas a “fortune,” though it killed over 100 people.

federal courts
As Trump Fumes, GOP Advances Party Goal of Appointing Lifetime Federal Judges
By Matt Stieb

The Senate Judiciary advanced the nomination of a lawyer who has never tried a case, a reminder of why the GOP Establishment tolerates Trump.

10/17/2019trump impeachment

trump impeachment
Poll: Only a Minority of Republicans Are Sure Trump Is Innocent
By Ed Kilgore

New findings from Pew suggest there are more Democrats certain Trump committed impeachable offenses than Republicans who are certain he didn’t.

America Owed Better to Elijah Cummings
By Zak Cheney-Rice

The congressman died trying to protect vulnerable Americans from Trump.

10/17/2019intelligencer chats

intelligencer chats
Is Annoying People the Right Way to Combat Climate Change?
By Benjamin Hart and David Wallace-Wells

Intelligencer staffers discuss the intentionally divisive tactics of an upstart movement.

climate change
Florida GOP Regrets ‘Lost’ Decade on Climate Change
By Matt Stieb

The party is recovering from Rick Scott’s ban on using the phrase “climate change” ⁠— though isn’t quite ready to embrace climate policy.


Rikers Island is set to close, in a momentous change to New York’s prison system
One 886-bed jail will tower over shops and restaurants in Downtown Brooklyn. Another will be next to a subway yard in Queens. In the Bronx, a jail will replace a Police Department tow pound. And another jail will rise in the shadow of City Hall in Manhattan.That is at the heart of a plan for a landmark overhaul of New York City’s corrections system, which will culminate with the closing of Rikers Island, the jail complex with nearly 10,000 beds that has become notorious for chronic abuse, neglect and mismanagement.The City Council approved the proposal on Thursday, a decision that seemed nearly impossible just a few years ago and that supporters say immediately places New York City at the forefront of a national movement to reverse decades of mass incarceration that disproportionately affected black and Hispanic people.

Subscribe to the newsletter news

We hate SPAM and promise to keep your email address safe

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Top Stories

To Top