Connect with us

My Wordpress

GOP Leader Has One Chart Showing Why Republicans Hate Democracy


GOP Leader Has One Chart Showing Why Republicans Hate Democracy

GOP Leader Has One Chart Showing Why Republicans Hate Democracy

Ad will collapse in

Photo: Alex Wong/Getty Images

Donald Trump’s gross, overt authoritarianism has both accelerated and dramatized a much deeper hostility to democratic principles on the right that predates him. House Majority Leader Kevin McCarthy illustrates that tendency with a tweet denouncing impeachment as illegitimate:

In this one arresting image, McCarthy layers together a series of popular anti-democratic (small-d, not large-D) arguments on the right that are dangerous on their own, and perfectly absurd in combination.

To begin with, any elected president who is being impeached by definition has won the support of a large number of voters. There’s no way to impeach losing candidates. If you don’t think a president who won a lot of votes should be impeached, you don’t think impeachment belongs in the Constitution at all.

Second, Trump of course finished second in the national vote. He did manage to eke out an Electoral College win owing to the peculiarities of that mechanism (which was designed to create independent electors who would choose a candidate, on the assumption voters had no way of familiarizing themselves with candidates from distant areas) and the randomness of its all-or-nothing blocs (move the Upper Peninsula to Wisconsin and the Florida Panhandle to Alabama, and Hillary Clinton wins the Electoral College.)

Trump and his supporters have relentlessly revised out of existence his national popular vote defeat (in part by fabricating claims of mass voter fraud) and to inflate his narrow Electoral College win into a metaphysical expression of the national will. Their favorite propaganda device is to take advantage of the lower population density of Republican areas to create a visual image of red implying this majority. McCarthy’s map takes that method to the next level by literally erasing Democratic-voting areas, and citing Trump’s vote total without also citing his opponent’s larger total.

That doesn’t make Trump’s win illegitimate. The rules are the rules. But of course those same rules say that Congress has the right to initiate impeachment hearings if it believes the president has committed high crimes and misdemeanors, leaving it to them to define those terms. What’s more, the House was elected by a fairly commanding national majority.

Third, the House is not “reversing” the 2016 election results. If the House impeaches Trump, the Senate will hold a trial, and only if 20 Republican Senators join every Democrat could Trump be removed from office. Even that result would not “reverse” the election, since reversing it would make Hillary Clinton president. It would merely install in office the person Donald Trump entrusted to take over the job.

Any argument that rationalizes Trump winning the presidency while finishing second would also rationalize the House impeaching him. There’s no internally coherent argument for elevating the Electoral College mechanism over the impeachment mechanism. Save one: that the Republican Party is entitled to permanent unchallenged rule.

GOP Leader’s One Chart Shows Why Republicans Hate Democracy

Promoted links by Taboola

11/1/2019intelligencer chats

intelligencer chats
Why Is the Stock Market Doing So Well?
By Josh Barro and Benjamin Hart

Intelligencer staffers discuss what to make of a bevy of economic signals this week.

Beto Drops Out
By Sarah Jones

The former congressman from Texas had failed to find much footing in the primary race.


Beto drops out
Former Representative Beto O’Rourke of Texas is dropping out of the presidential race, ending a campaign in which he struggled for months to recapture the energy of his insurgent 2018 Senate candidacy on a national stage full of other big personalities and liberal champions.Mr. O’Rourke made the decision to quit the race in the middle of this week, on the eve of a gathering Friday of Democratic presidential candidates in Iowa, according to people familiar with his thinking. He is not expected to run for any other office in 2020, despite persistent efforts by party leaders and political donors to coax him into another bid for the Senate.

11/1/2019medicare for all

medicare for all
Elizabeth Warren’s Medicare for All Plan Is a Smart Storytelling Device
By Eric Levitz

Warren has an excellent plan for reframing the debate over Medicare for All — and a clever but flawed one for how to pay for the program.


An expected but effective burn from Elizabeth Warren

👀 Elizabeth Warren says Joe Biden is “running in the wrong presidential primary” after his attacks on her health care plan.“Democrats are not going to win by repeating Republican talking points.”

11/1/2019the national interest

the national interest
GOP Leader Has One Chart Showing Why Republicans Hate Democracy
By Jonathan Chait

Kevin McCarthy doesn’t understand the Constitution, also doesn’t care.


Extra time for one of the blockbusters of the SCOTUS term

Supreme Court supersizes DACA argument on Nov. 12, to 80 minutes rather than the usual 60.

Delta’s Flight Attendants Are Trying To Unionize, Again
By Sarah Jones

The campaign will be a major labor battle during a pivotal election cycle.

vision 2020
Elizabeth Warren Isn’t Backing Down From Medicare for All
By Sarah Jones

The candidate released her funding proposal this morning, which includes tougher tax enforcement and draining a Pentagon “slush fund.”

Grassley Bumping Graham As Judiciary Committee Chairman
By Ed Kilgore

It’s got nothing to do with impeachment, and everything to do with seniority.

11/1/2019interesting times

interesting times
Andrew Sullivan: The Hard Questions About Young People and Gender Transitions
By Andrew Sullivan

The ideological campaign to affirm trans kids and teens, while admirable and often essential, also risks overreach.

vision 2020
Can Anyone Catch the Big Four in Iowa?
By Ed Kilgore

Biden, Buttigieg, Sanders, and Warren are far ahead of the rest of the field in Iowa, and there likely won’t be more than four tickets out of there.

Real Life. Real News. Real Voices

Help us tell more of the stories that matter

Become a founding member

The Week in Impeachment: Ukrainegate Becomes a Sitcom?
By Eric Levitz

This week’s events made it clear that the impeachment saga is more sitcom than drama: The plot never thickens, the joke just heightens.


Everyone at Deadspin has now been fired or quit

And with that, it’s over. Deadspin no longer employs a single writer or editor. I am gutted but so very proud of this group of people.Deadspin was a good website.

11/1/2019the national interest

the national interest
Trump: The Soviet Witch Coup Has Found Me Innocent
By Jonathan Chait

That’s not how witch hunts or show trials work.


Iowa is looking totally up for grabs

New NYT/Siena poll in Iowa just out:Warren 22%Sanders 19%Buttigieg 18%Biden 17%Klobuchar 4%Harris 3%Yang 3%Booker 2%Gabbard 2%Steyer 2%Everyone else 1% or less


A good jobs report, but there’s still persistent slow wage growth

BREAKING: US economy added 128,000 jobs in October, beating expectations, esp. because of the GM strike impact. Unemployment rate rises to 3.6% (up slightly from 3.5%)Wages: Up just 3.0% in the past year year

Why I’m Leaving New York: A Donald J. Trump Story
By Matt Stieb

Trump announced on Thursday night that he would move his permanent residence from Trump Tower to Mar-a-Lago after his presidency.

Inside Trump Country’s Hottest Club: The Halloween Eve Witch-Hunt Party
By Olivia Nuzzi

In a sports complex in Manheim, PA, the Trump-Pence 2020 Witch-Hunt Halloween Party felt like a kid’s birthday party, but for adult Trump fanatics.

Trump Pick for Cybersecurity Adviser Rudy Giuliani Couldn’t Unlock Phone: Report
By Matt Stieb

Shortly after becoming Trump’s cybersecurity adviser, Giuliani visited an Apple Store in San Francisco because he forgot his phone’s passcode.

10/31/2019donald trump jr.

donald trump jr.
Donald Trump Jr. Thinks His Rust Belt Boarding School Made Him a Regular Guy
By Ed Kilgore

His father went to a Pennsylvania Rust Belt school, too, called Wharton!

Adam Neumann’s Time at WeWork Is Over, But His Troubles Aren’t
By Sarah Jones

A new lawsuit accuses the disgraced CEO of pregnancy discrimination.


Save your popcorn

US District Court Judge Leon in Washington wont hear arguments till December 10 for witness Charles Kupperman. So no Kupperman before that and potentially John Bolton. Kupperman and Bolton share the same attorney.

10/31/2019elections of 2019

elections of 2019
Republicans Going All-Out Red Scare in Off-Year Elections
By Ed Kilgore

In Kentucky and even in the more moderate Virginia, Republicans are smearing all Democrats as terrifying socialists. It will get much worse next year.


Some thoughts from the supposedly reasonable Trump family member

“…surrounded by enemies and spies catching and perverting every word that falls from my lips or flows from my pen, and inventing where facts fail them.” -Thomas Jefferson’s reflections on Washington, D.C. in a letter to his daughter Martha.Some things never change, dad!

10/31/2019just asking questions

just asking questions
Danielle Citron on Deepfakes and the Katie Hill Scandal
By Brian Feldman

The recent Genius Grant winner has been studying online harassment for years, well before it became mainstream news.

10/31/2019international affairs

international affairs
Everything You Need to Know About the Global Protest Wave
By Adam K. Raymond

From Lebanon to Chile, demonstrators are taking to the streets to demand changes from their governments.

Subscribe to the newsletter news

We hate SPAM and promise to keep your email address safe

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Top Stories

To Top